Water Heater Heating Element Guide: Signs of Failure, Costs, DIY Replacement & Testing

water heater heating element
​​Related Keywords​​:

In a water heater, what is the heating element?
How can you tell whether a water heater element is defective?
The cost of replacing an element in a hot water heater
Can one replace a water heater element by oneself?
Water heating element
How to test hot water heater element

Introduction

In electric water heaters, the main component heating water is a heating element found in a water heater. Whether you are analyzing a broken component or thinking about DIY replacement, knowledge of its function, symptoms of failure, and costs will help you to save money and time. Your main queries—about how to test components, project replacement costs, and safely carry repairs—are addressed in this guide.

A water tank, what is its heating element?

An electrically driven device, the water heater heating element, uses resistive heating to transfer heat to water. Controlled by thermostats, most home tanks have upper and lower two elements.

​​ Key details​​:

For durability, use stainless steel or nichrome wire (nickel-chromium alloy).
Residential use calls for power ratings of 3,500W to 5,500W (240V).
​​Types​​:
​​ Flange-style​​: Bolted into the tank (common in older models).
​​ Over-the-side​​: Easy installation in modern tanks.

​​Example​​: A. O. Example Smith’s PowerCore® parts employ spiraled nichrome coils for quicker heat transfer.

How can you determine whether a water heater element is faulty?

​​ Common signs of a faulty heating element​​:

​Symptom​​Likely Cause​
No hot waterBurned-out element (open circuit)
Lukewarm waterHigh resistance or mineral buildup
Popping/rumbling noisesLime scale on element
Frequent tripped breakersShort circuit in element

​​Testing steps​​:

​​(1),Continuity test​​: Use a multimeter to check for infinite resistance (open circuit = bad element).
​​(2),Resistance test​​: Calculate expected ohms (R = V²/P). An element rated at 4,500W/240V would have roughly 12.9 Ω.
(3),Visual inspection: Search for burnt marks, corrosion, or fractures.

Replacing a water heater element: what does it cost?

​​ Cost breakdown​​:

​​DIY parts​​: 20–80 per element (brand-dependent).
Example: Rheem elements cost 30–60; A.O. Smith ranges 50–100.
​​Labor​​: 100–200 (if hiring a plumber).
​​Total DIY cost​​: 50–150.
​​Professional service​​: 150–300.

​​Note​​: Replacing both elements often costs less than $250 (parts + labor).

Could you personally replace a water heater element?

​​Yes​​, with basic tools and precautions:

​​Tools needed​​:

   Screwdrivers
   Socket wrench (7/16" or 1-1/2")
   Multimeter
   Safety gloves/goggles

​​Step-by-step guide​​:

(1),Turn off power at the circuit breaker.
(2),Drain the tank (remove 5–10 gallons via the drain valve).
(3),Remove the access panel and disconnect wires from the old element.
(4),Unscrew the element with a socket wrench.
(5),Install the new element, apply thread sealant, and reassemble.

​​Pro tip​​: Replace the thermal fuse and upper/lower thermostats if they show wear.

water heater heating elements
water heater heating elements

How to Test a Hot Water Heater Element

​​ Tools required​​: Digital multimeter, insulated gloves.

​​Steps​​:

​​(1),Turn off power​​ and drain the tank.
​​(2),Remove the element​​ and disconnect wires.
​​(3),Test continuity​​:
Set multimeter to continuity/beep mode.
Place probes on terminals. A working element beeps; no beep = faulty.
​​(4),Measure resistance​​:
Compare readings to calculated values (e.g., 12.9 Ω for 4,500W/240V).

​​Common failures​​:

​​Open circuit​​: Infinite resistance (element burned out).
​​Short circuit​​: Resistance <5 Ω (internal insulation failure).

Cost-Saving Tips & FAQs

​​ FAQs​​:

  1. ​​How long do water heater elements last?​​
    ​​Average lifespan​​: 8–12 years. Hard water areas may reduce this to 5 years.
  2. ​​Can I use a higher-wattage element?​​
    Only if the thermostat matches the wattage. Oversizing wastes energy.
  3. ​​Why is my water heater making noise?​​
    Lime scale buildup insulates the element, causing overheating and popping sounds.
  4. ​​Are gas and electric elements interchangeable?​​
    No—gas heaters use burners, not electric elements.

About Zhongshan Jinhong Electric Heating Tech Co., Ltd.

As a leading manufacturer of ​​water heating elements​​, we provide:
✅ OEM/ODM solutions for brands like Rheem, A.O. Smith, and Bradford White.
✅ Elements rated for 10,000+ hours (tested under ASTM D2157 standards).
✅ Anti-corrosion coatings for hard water regions.
✅ Global shipping with 2-year warranty.

Contact us for bulk orders or prototypes ,Thanks