How to Know When to Replace Your Electric Water Heater Element

Table of Contents

How to Know When to Replace Your Electric Water Heater Element

When you notice inconsistent water temperatures or strange noises from your electric water heater, you should consider inspecting the Heating Element. Many homeowners overlook these warning signs, but taking time to check electric water heater components can prevent costly repairs. Prompt replacement matters. The following table highlights how a faulty element affects both energy efficiency and safety:

Impact on Energy EfficiencyDescription
Increased Energy BillsUsing a faulty element causes the heater to work harder, leading to higher energy costs.
Overheating RisksMismatched elements can cause overheating, increasing fire hazards.
Strain on SystemConstant operation due to inefficiency puts extra strain on the water heater.

You protect your home by recognizing issues early. Jinzhong Electric Heating and other heating element manufacturers recommend routine checks of household appliance heating elements to reduce risks.

Signs You Should Check Electric Water Heater Element

Signs You Should Check Electric Water Heater Element

No Hot Water

You expect hot water when you turn on the tap. If you only get cold water, you should check electric water heater components immediately. A failed upper heating element often causes a complete lack of hot water throughout your home. This issue affects all faucets and appliances. The following table outlines common causes for no hot water and how they impact your system:

Cause of Lack of Hot WaterDescription
Failed Upper ElementResults in no hot water throughout the home, affecting all faucets and appliances.
Failed Lower ElementLeads to lukewarm water; showers may start hot but turn cold during use.
Electrical IssuesCan affect either element, causing inconsistent water temperatures or frequent reset button tripping.

If you notice no hot water, you should also consider electrical problems or thermostat malfunctions. However, heating element failure remains one of the most frequent reasons for this symptom.

Water Not Hot Enough

You may notice that your water never reaches the desired temperature. This symptom often points to a faulty lower heating element. Showers may start warm but quickly turn cold. You should not ignore this warning sign. Insufficient hot water can disrupt daily routines and signal deeper problems within your electric water heater.

To confirm if the heating element is the cause, follow these diagnostic steps:

  1. Check the thermostat settings to ensure they are correctly set.
  2. Test the heating elements using a multimeter; a reading outside the specified range indicates a faulty element.
  3. Inspect the heating elements for any signs of corrosion or mineral buildup.
  4. Check for tripped circuit breakers, as electrical issues can cause heating failures.
  5. Consider sediment buildup in the tank, which can affect heating efficiency.

Tip: Regularly inspecting your water heater for corrosion or mineral buildup helps prevent future problems and extends the lifespan of your appliance.

Fluctuating Temperatures

You may experience inconsistent water temperatures during use. Sometimes the water feels hot, then suddenly turns lukewarm or cold. Fluctuating temperatures often indicate that one or both heating elements are failing. Inconsistent heating can also result from electrical issues or sediment buildup inside the tank.

Recent surveys highlight several common symptoms that suggest you should check your electric water heater element:

  • Strange noises, such as popping or rumbling, often signal sediment build-up.
  • Discolored water can indicate corrosion or sediment.
  • Lack of hot water points to a failing element.
  • Fluctuating water temperatures suggest element issues.
  • Frequent repairs may mean it is time for replacement.
  • Water heaters older than 8-12 years are more prone to failure.
  • High energy bills can indicate inefficiency in older models.

If you notice any of these symptoms, prompt action helps maintain safety and efficiency. Addressing problems early prevents costly repairs and ensures reliable hot water for your household.

Strange Noises

You might hear unusual sounds coming from your water heater. These noises often signal problems that require your attention. Different sounds can point to specific issues inside the tank or with the heating element. The table below outlines the most common noises and what they mean:

Noise TypeDescription
Popping and CracklingSediment buildup causes water to get trapped and boil, creating popping or crackling sounds.
Hissing and SizzlingWater leaks onto the heating element, producing hissing or sizzling noises.
HummingA loose connection can cause the heating element to vibrate, resulting in a humming sound.

If you notice any of these noises, you should check electric water heater components for sediment buildup or loose connections. Ignoring these sounds can lead to further damage or reduced efficiency. Regular maintenance helps prevent these issues and keeps your system running smoothly.

Discolored or Rusty Water

When you see rusty or discolored water coming from your hot water tap, you should not ignore it. This problem often points to corrosion inside the tank or mineral buildup. You may notice the following:

  • Rust-colored water from hot taps usually means corrosion inside the water heater, especially in units over eight years old.
  • Mineral buildup can also cause water discoloration.
  • Discolored or rusty water signals that the water heater may need repair, often due to corrosion.
  • Noticing discoloration in hot water is a common sign of internal corrosion.

Discolored water affects both water quality and appliance lifespan. If you see these signs, consider scheduling an inspection to determine if the heating element or the tank itself needs attention.

Tripped Breaker or Blown Fuse

A tripped breaker or blown fuse can indicate a serious problem with your electric water heater. Faulty thermostats or overheating elements often draw too much current, which can overload your electrical system. The table below summarizes the main causes and risks:

Evidence DescriptionSource
Faulty thermostats and overheating elements can cause excessive current draw, leading to tripped breakers or blown fuses.Electric Hot Water Heater Repair FAQs Set-2
Problems at the electric water heater can subject the breaker to protracted overcurrent conditions, increasing failure risk.Electric Hot Water Heater Repair FAQs Set-2
Overcurrent and heating from issues at the electric water heater can increase the risk of circuit or breaker failure.Electric Hot Water Heater Repair FAQs Set-2

You should address electrical issues immediately to avoid fire hazards or permanent damage to your system. If you experience frequent breaker trips, consult a professional to inspect the wiring and heating elements.

How to Safely Check Electric Water Heater Element

How to Safely Check Electric Water Heater Element

Power Off and Safety Precautions

Shutting Off Power at the Breaker

You must always begin by disconnecting power before you check electric water heater components. Locate the correct breaker in your electrical panel and switch it off. This step prevents electrical shock and keeps you safe during inspection.

Verifying No Electrical Current

After you shut off the breaker, confirm that no electricity flows to the water heater. Use a non-contact voltage tester to check all exposed wires and terminals. Double-check each terminal before you touch any internal parts. The following table outlines industry-standard safety precautions you should follow:

Safety PrecautionDescription
Disconnect PowerAlways disconnect power at the source before touching any internal parts of your water heater.
Confirm Power OffUse a non-contact voltage tester to ensure that the power is truly off before proceeding.
Use Insulated ToolsAlways use insulated tools to reduce the risk of electrical shock. Wear protective clothing and remove jewelry.
Double-Check for ElectricityUse a voltage tester again on all exposed terminals before touching any heating elements or wiring.

Tip: Never skip safety checks. You protect yourself and your home by following these steps every time.

Accessing the Heating Element

Removing Covers and Insulation

Once you confirm the power is off, gather the necessary tools and protective equipment. You need a screwdriver to remove the access panel and insulation. Put on work gloves to protect your hands from sharp edges and hot surfaces. Use a flashlight to improve visibility inside the water heater.

  • Multimeter
  • Screwdriver
  • Non-contact voltage tester
  • Work gloves
  • Flashlight

You should also wear safety glasses to shield your eyes from dust and debris. Remove the outer cover and insulation carefully. Place screws and panels in a safe spot so you can reassemble the unit later.

Locating Element Terminals

After you remove the cover, locate the heating element terminals. You will see two wires connected to each element. Identify the terminals before you begin testing the element. Make sure the area is dry and free from water leaks.

Using a Multimeter for Testing

Setting Multimeter to Ohms

You need a multimeter to test heating elements. Set the multimeter to the ohms (Ω) setting. This mode allows you to measure resistance and check for continuity in the heating element.

Checking Continuity and Resistance

Touch one probe to each terminal of the heating element. A working element will show a specific resistance value, usually between 10 and 30 ohms. If the multimeter reads infinite resistance, the element is faulty. You should also test for ground faults by placing one probe on a terminal and the other on the metal tank. No reading should appear; any resistance indicates a problem.

Follow these best practices when you test heating elements:

  1. Set your multimeter to ohms/resistance.
  2. Use a non-contact voltage tester to confirm the power is off before handling wires.
  3. Check for ground faults by testing between the element terminal and the metal tank.

Note: If you are unsure how to test heating elements, consult a licensed electrician. Professional help ensures accurate results and keeps you safe.

Interpreting Multimeter Test Results

Normal Resistance Readings

When you test your electric water heater element with a multimeter, you want to see a resistance value within the normal range. This number tells you if the element can still heat water efficiently. Most functioning heating elements show resistance between 5 and 25 ohms. Some manufacturers recommend a slightly narrower range, usually between 9 and 12 ohms, but readings up to 20 ohms are still considered acceptable.

Resistance Range (Ohms)
5 – 25
Resistance Range (Ohms)
9 – 12 (up to 20)

If your multimeter displays a value in these ranges, your element is likely working as intended. You should always compare your reading to the specifications listed on your water heater’s label. Consistent resistance means your system can deliver hot water reliably.

Tip: Always test both the upper and lower heating elements. A single faulty element can disrupt your entire hot water supply.

Signs of a Burnt-Out Element

You can spot a burnt-out water heater element by looking for specific symptoms and test results. If you notice only cold water coming from your taps, the top element may have failed. Lukewarm water often points to a malfunctioning upper element. If your hot water runs out quickly, the lower element could be the problem. Circuit breaker trips may signal that the element draws too much electricity.

When you use a multimeter, a healthy element shows resistance between 10 and 30 ohms. If you see a reading of 1 or 0, the element is broken and cannot heat water.

  • Only cold water from taps
  • Lukewarm water during showers
  • Hot water runs out quickly
  • Circuit breaker trips frequently
  • Multimeter shows 1 or 0 ohms

If you observe these signs, you should replace the faulty element to restore your water heater’s performance.

What Infinite Resistance Means

When your multimeter displays infinite resistance, you have found a serious problem. This reading means the circuit inside the heating element is open and cannot conduct electricity. You must replace the element to restore hot water.

A reading of infinite resistance (or no change on the display) indicates an open circuit, meaning the heating element is faulty and needs to be replaced.

Normal resistance readings for water heater elements typically fall between 10 and 17 ohms. If your test shows infinite ohms, the element has failed and may be grounded. You should not attempt to use the water heater until you install a new element.

  • Infinite resistance means the element is no longer functional.
  • The element cannot heat water or complete the circuit.
  • Replacement is the only solution for restoring hot water.

You protect your home and ensure safe operation by interpreting multimeter results correctly. Prompt action prevents further damage and keeps your water heater running efficiently.

When Results Are Unclear

You may encounter situations where your multimeter readings do not match the expected values. Sometimes, the numbers fluctuate or fall outside the normal resistance range. You might see inconsistent results between the upper and lower heating elements. These unclear results can make it difficult to decide whether you need to replace the element or investigate further.

You should start by double-checking your testing process. Review each step to ensure you followed safety protocols and used the correct multimeter settings. You may want to repeat the test to confirm your findings. Sometimes, a loose connection or a dirty terminal can affect your readings. Clean the terminals with a dry cloth and tighten any loose wires before testing again.

Tip: Always use a calibrated multimeter and inspect your test leads for damage. Faulty equipment can produce unreliable results.

If you still see unclear readings, consider these possible causes:

  • Partial Element Failure: The heating element may work intermittently. You might notice hot water at times, but the temperature fluctuates. This condition can produce resistance readings that change each time you test.
  • Sediment Buildup: Mineral deposits inside the tank can insulate the element. You may see normal resistance, but the element cannot heat water efficiently. Inspect the tank for sediment and flush it if needed.
  • Electrical Issues: Problems with the thermostat, wiring, or breaker can mimic element failure. You should check these components if your test results remain ambiguous.
  • Multimeter Limitations: Some basic multimeters may not provide precise readings for low-resistance elements. You may need a more advanced tool for accurate diagnostics.

You can use the following troubleshooting checklist to clarify your results:

StepAction
Repeat the testConfirm readings with a second measurement
Inspect connectionsTighten and clean all terminals
Check equipmentUse a reliable, calibrated multimeter
Examine other partsInspect thermostat and wiring
Flush the tankRemove sediment buildup

If you cannot resolve the issue after following these steps, you should consider seeking professional help. A licensed plumber or electrician can perform advanced diagnostics and recommend the best solution. You protect your water heater and ensure safe operation by addressing unclear results promptly. Do not ignore ambiguous readings, as they may signal underlying problems that could worsen over time.

Note: You should never attempt repairs if you feel uncertain about your skills or the safety of the process. Professional assistance guarantees accurate results and protects your home.

What to Do If the Element Is Faulty

DIY Replacement Steps

If you discover a faulty heating element, you can attempt a replacement yourself by following a systematic approach. Always prioritize safety and accuracy during each step.

Draining the Water Heater Tank

  1. Turn off the power at the main electrical panel. Wait for the water to cool before proceeding.
  2. Shut off the cold water supply to the heater.
  3. Attach a garden hose to the drain valve at the bottom of the tank.
  4. Open the drain valve and allow the tank to empty completely.

Tip: Draining the tank prevents water spills and reduces the risk of burns during the replacement process.

Removing the Old Element

  1. Remove the access cover and insulation to expose the heating element.
  2. Use a multimeter to check for continuity and confirm the element is faulty.
  3. Disconnect the wires from the element terminals.
  4. Use an element wrench to unscrew and remove the old heating element.

Installing the New Element

  1. Insert the new heating element into the opening and tighten it securely.
  2. Reconnect the circuit wires to the new element terminals.
  3. Double-check all connections for tightness and proper placement.

Refilling and Testing

  1. Close the drain valve and remove the hose.
  2. Open the cold water supply and allow the tank to fill completely.
  3. Once the tank is full, restore power at the main panel.
  4. Replace the insulation and access cover.
  5. Monitor the water temperature to ensure the new element works correctly.

You should always check electric water heater performance after installation to confirm successful replacement.

When to Call a Professional

DIY replacement offers cost savings, but it comes with risks. High voltage inside water heaters can cause electrical shocks if you mishandle wiring. Incorrect installation may lead to water leaks, which can damage your home. Attempting repairs yourself may also void the manufacturer’s warranty, leaving you unprotected for future issues.

Consider hiring a licensed professional if you feel uncertain about any step. Professionals bring specialized tools and expertise, ensuring repairs meet safety standards. Many offer warranties on their work, providing peace of mind. You save time and avoid costly mistakes by relying on expert service.

Note: If you notice persistent issues or unclear test results, professional help guarantees safe and effective solutions.

Preventing Future Electric Water Heater Element Problems

Routine Maintenance Tips

You can extend the lifespan of your electric water heater element by following a few essential maintenance practices. Regular care helps your system run efficiently and reduces the risk of unexpected breakdowns. Consider these proven tips:

  • Flush the tank to remove sediment buildup. Sediment can insulate the heating element, causing it to overheat and fail prematurely.
  • Inspect and replace the anode rod as needed. The anode rod attracts corrosive minerals, protecting the tank and element from rust.
  • Adjust the thermostat settings for optimal energy efficiency and safety. Setting the temperature too high can stress the element and increase energy costs.
  • Insulate the water heater and pipes. Proper insulation reduces heat loss, helping your system maintain consistent water temperatures and lowering energy consumption.

Tip: Schedule these maintenance tasks at least once a year to keep your water heater in top condition.

Early Warning Signs to Watch For

You can prevent major problems by recognizing early warning signs of electric water heater element failure. Stay alert for these common indicators:

  • Inconsistent or no hot water often signals a failing heating element or sediment buildup.
  • Strange noises, such as popping or rumbling, suggest sediment accumulation inside the tank.
  • Discolored or rusty water may point to corrosion or a deteriorating anode rod.
  • Water around the tank indicates possible leaks or internal failure.
  • An older water heater, especially one over 8–12 years old, faces a higher risk of element failure.
  • Increased energy bills can result from decreased heating efficiency.
  • Fluctuating water pressure may mean sediment is clogging the system.

If you notice any of these symptoms, take action quickly. Addressing issues early helps you avoid costly repairs and ensures reliable hot water for your home.

Scheduling Regular Inspections

You should schedule a professional inspection of your electric water heater at least once a year. During this visit, a technician checks the heating element, thermostat, valves, and tank for signs of wear or corrosion. The technician also examines the anode rod and advises you if it needs replacement.

  1. Book an annual inspection with a qualified technician.
  2. Ensure the technician inspects all critical components, including the heating element and thermostat.
  3. Request feedback on the condition of your anode rod and ask about replacement if necessary.

Regular inspections help you catch small problems before they become major failures. By staying proactive, you protect your investment and enjoy consistent hot water year-round.

Safety Tips When You Check Electric Water Heater

Electrical Safety Guidelines

You must treat your electric water heater with respect. High voltage and water create a dangerous combination. Always turn off the power at the breaker before you begin any inspection or repair. Use a non-contact voltage tester to confirm that no electricity flows to the unit. Never rely on just flipping the switch—double-check for your safety.

Wear insulated gloves and safety glasses to protect yourself from accidental shocks and debris. Keep your workspace dry. Water on the floor or around the heater increases the risk of electrical shock. Remove any jewelry or metal objects from your hands and wrists. These items can conduct electricity and put you at greater risk.

Tip: If you feel unsure about any step, stop and consult a licensed electrician. Your safety comes first.

Avoiding Damage During Testing

You want your water heater to last as long as possible. Handle all components with care during testing. Use the correct tools, such as a properly calibrated multimeter and an element wrench designed for your heater model. Avoid using excessive force when removing covers or terminals. Gentle handling prevents accidental damage to wires and insulation.

Keep track of all screws and small parts. Place them in a container so you do not lose them during the process. When you remove insulation, set it aside in a clean, dry area. This practice helps you reinstall it correctly and maintain your heater’s energy efficiency.

A table can help you remember the best practices:

TaskBest Practice
Removing coversUse the right screwdriver
Handling wiresAvoid pulling or bending excessively
Testing with a multimeterConfirm correct settings
Reinstalling insulationKeep it dry and intact

Note: Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions for your specific water heater model.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Many homeowners make avoidable errors when testing or replacing a water heater element. You can prevent costly problems by steering clear of these common mistakes:

  1. You might select the wrong size or type of heating element for your water heater. Always check your model’s specifications before purchasing a replacement.
  2. Forgetting to replace the rubber gasket can lead to leaks. Always install a new gasket with the new element.
  3. Overtightening the element may damage the tank or make future removal difficult. Tighten the element firmly, but do not use excessive force.
  4. Undertightening the element can cause leaks around the installation point. Make sure the element is secure, but not forced.
  5. Incorrect wiring connections often happen when you do not document the original setup. Take a photo or make notes before disconnecting wires.
  6. Ignoring safety steps, such as turning off the power and verifying with a multimeter, puts you at risk of electrical shock.

⚠️ Alert: Skipping safety steps or rushing through the process can result in injury or expensive repairs. Take your time and follow each step carefully.

By following these guidelines, you protect both yourself and your water heater. Careful preparation and attention to detail ensure a safe and successful inspection or repair.

Cost and Replacement Options for Electric Water Heater Elements

Average Replacement Costs

When you plan to replace electric water heater elements, you should understand the typical costs involved. Most homeowners in the United States spend between $150 and $350 for this service. This price includes both the part and the labor required for installation. If you choose a high-efficiency or specialty element, you may see higher costs. You can often save money by handling the replacement yourself, but you must always prioritize safety and proper installation.

  • The typical cost to replace an electric water heater element ranges from $150 to $350.
  • This estimate covers both the part and labor.
  • High-efficiency or specialty heating elements may increase the total cost.

Tip: Always request a detailed quote from your technician before agreeing to any repairs. This step helps you avoid unexpected expenses.

Choosing the Right Element

Selecting the correct replacement for your water heater ensures reliable performance and energy efficiency. You should consider several important factors before making a purchase. The table below outlines what you need to evaluate:

FactorDescription
Energy EfficiencyConsider how much energy the element uses to heat water effectively.
CostEvaluate the price of the element and its impact on your budget.
DurabilityLook for elements that have a long lifespan to reduce replacement frequency.
CompatibilityEnsure the element fits with your existing water heater model.
Hot Water Usage PatternsAssess your household’s hot water needs to choose an appropriate element.

You should also check the type of immersion water heater you own and confirm compatibility with your system. Efficiency and durability play a key role in long-term savings. Cost matters, but you should not sacrifice quality for a lower price. Always match the new element to your water heater’s specifications to avoid installation issues.

Repair vs. Full Replacement

You face a choice between repairing your water heater by replacing heating elements or opting for a full unit replacement. Repairing a faulty element usually costs between $200 and $300. This option works well if your water heater is relatively new and in good condition. Full water heater replacement, on the other hand, ranges from $800 to $2,500 or more. While this investment is higher, a new unit can offer better energy efficiency and improved performance.

  • Repairing heating elements typically costs $200 to $300.
  • Full water heater replacement costs range from $800 to $2,500 or more.
  • Replacing a heating element is budget-friendly in the short term.
  • Newer units from a full replacement may provide long-term savings and better reliability.

You should weigh the age and condition of your current water heater. If your unit is over ten years old or shows signs of multiple failures, a full replacement may serve you better. For newer systems with isolated issues, replacing the heating element often restores full function at a lower cost.


You protect your home and save money when you routinely check electric water heater components. Always turn off the power before you inspect or replace an element. Listen for unusual noises, look for corrosion, and use a multimeter to confirm proper function. Early action prevents leaks, sediment buildup, and costly repairs. If you notice persistent issues, consult a licensed electrician or plumber with water heater certifications.

Common IssueDescription
Faulty Heating ElementCauses lukewarm or cold water; requires prompt replacement.
Sediment BuildupReduces efficiency; annual flushing helps maintain performance.
LeaksCan lead to water damage; professional repair is often necessary.

FAQ

How often should you check your electric water heater element?

You should inspect your electric water heater element at least once a year. Regular checks help you catch early signs of wear, corrosion, or inefficiency. Routine maintenance extends the lifespan of your water heater.

What tools do you need to test a water heater element?

You need a multimeter, a screwdriver, insulated gloves, and a non-contact voltage tester. These tools help you safely access and test the heating element for continuity and resistance.

Can you replace a water heater element without draining the tank?

You must drain the tank before replacing the element. Draining prevents water spills and reduces the risk of burns. Always turn off the power and water supply before starting the process.

What does it mean if your multimeter shows infinite resistance?

Infinite resistance means the heating element has failed. The circuit inside the element is open, so it cannot heat water. You need to replace the faulty element to restore hot water.

Is it safe to replace a water heater element yourself?

You can replace the element yourself if you follow safety guidelines. Always turn off the power, use insulated tools, and verify no electrical current. If you feel unsure, contact a licensed professional.

How do you choose the right replacement element?

Check your water heater’s specifications. Match the wattage, voltage, and size. Consider energy efficiency and durability. Use the table below for quick reference:

SpecificationWhat to Check
WattageMatch your model
VoltageConfirm accuracy
SizeFit your tank
TypeScrew-in or bolt

What are signs that your water heater element needs replacement?

You may notice no hot water, lukewarm water, fluctuating temperatures, strange noises, or discolored water. Frequent breaker trips also indicate possible element failure. Early detection helps you avoid costly repairs.

When should you call a professional for water heater repairs?

Call a professional if you feel unsure about electrical safety, notice persistent issues, or see unclear test results. Licensed technicians ensure safe, accurate repairs and protect your warranty.

Picture of Mari Cheng

Mari Cheng

Hello everyone, I am Mari Cheng, the "electric heating person" of Jinzhong Electric Heating Technology. Our factory has been engaged in electric heating components for 30 years and has served more than 1,000 domestic and foreign customers. In the following blogs, I will talk about the real knowledge of electric heating components, the production stories in the factory, and the real needs of customers. If you have any questions, please comment or poke me directly, I will tell you everything I know~

Need Help?

If you have any questions, please contact us for help. We will also provide the latest quotation and free samples